面试官问? 为何众多人讲? Go语言的多线程相较Java语言的多线程要快呢, 是这样子的吗?我因为 Go 协程轻Java 线程重。面试官: 你所讲的“轻”, 究竟是指单个任务执行得更为迅速, 还是能够将更多并发给挂起来? 在Go里面运行的真的是线程吗? 倘若Java的JIT十分强大, 为何线上众多服务一开始还是会觉得Go更加轻? Java 21虚拟线程出现之后, 这句话还能有多少成立?很多人就是在这里被问住的。由于这道题极易被答成这样一句口号, 即 Go 协程具备轻量级的特性, 而 Java 线程则具有较重量级的特征, 所以 Go 的执行速度会更快。这句话不能说全错但它最大的问题是把“快”这件事说糊了。真实工程里最常见的场景往往是这种聚合接口所以这道题真正该追问的不是“谁快”这两个字而是将, 这几个, 问题, 问准确, 之后, 这道题, 才, 不会, 停留在, “Go协程轻, Java线程重”, 这种, 口号, 层面。1. 这道题到底在比什么不少人在听闻“Go 比 Java 快”之时, 脑海之中迅即浮现出语言执行效率这一概念。但是, 平常在线上所常见的出现那种“Go 更轻、更能扛并发”的感觉, 其主语通常并非是单条指令跑得更快, 而是, 当请求量逐渐上升、阻塞等待变得越来越多、并发任务数量持续增长的时候, Go 能够相较于其他更易于把这些任务经由一项更为低下的花销连接在整套系统之中。1.1. 为什么这不是热循环性能题倘若将场景转变为纯粹的 CPU 密集型热循环, 好比存在大量的数值计算, 以及热点方法长时间反复地执行, 那么 Java 的即时编译 JIT也就是 Just-In-Time极有可能把代码优化得相当激进, 其结果不一定会比 Go 逊色。所以线上那句“Go 更快”大多数时候真正指的是这压根儿不是在比“哪门语言的 for 循环更加给力”, 而实际上是在较量并发承载成本。1.2. 主比较口径先定清这篇文章的主线比较默认是很多人形成“Go 更轻”这样的直觉, 那是由于这一情况, 它起始于特定阶段, 也就是传统 Java 线程池的那些时期, 是这么来的。要是把Java 21的虚拟线程掺和进来一块儿讲, 那结论极易乱套。因而更稳妥的做法是, 先是把主线阐述明白, 之后再专门另外补充一小节虚拟线程边界。1.3. 首先将主判断放置下来。在诸多情形之中, Go展现出相较于传统Java线程模型更为快速的态势, 并非源于Go使得单个任务运行得更为效率, 而是在于相关创建、调度以及阻塞等待所产生的成本更为低廉, 因而它更易于承受海量的并发情况。后面拆的就是这句话到底成立在什么地方。2. 嗯Java平台线程, 对啦Java虚拟线程呢, 究竟差在了哪里, 到底差在了何方?先不谈性能先看三种并发单位到底挂在哪一层。先把承载关系摊开后面的成本差异才不容易说串。2.1. Go 的 是用户态并发单位Go 里真正大量调度的是不是 OS 线程本身。官方 文档把调度器拆成三层这个设计最关键的一点是任务数量和底层线程数量被拆开了。也就是说这一步一拆后面很多成本就都变了。2.2. 为什么能起很多个由于, 从起始点开始, 就并非是凭借“给予你一整套完整的 OS 线程套餐状况”来实施资源分配操作的。Go文档所给予的说法是: 用户栈起步于一个十分微小的起始点, 在典型的实现情形当中是2K, 随后依照需求进行增长以及收缩。其意义在于, 当并发执行单元刚刚被创建出来的时候, 并不需要一开始就背负上一整套完整线程所带来的成本。若一个刚创建的并发执行单元, 一开始就背负一份较大的固定栈, 那么一旦任务数量增多, 内存以及内核资源会率先承受不住。然而, 其想法并非如此, 它默认先给予一份极小的起步成本, 待到真的需要更深调用栈时再进行扩充。所以 便宜第一层便宜就在这里起步资源占用小。2.3. Java 平台线程为什么更重将 1:1 线程于 OS 进行映射的状态中, 通常被称作平台线程, 官方文档针对这样事项描述得很直接。这句话所表达的意思并非是“Java线程设计存在不足”, 而是其采用的是一套古老而悠久、且甚为明确的方式, 这方式被人们视作典范那般源远流长、被大众赞誉为直观那般清晰明了:这种模型的好处也很明显但它的问题也很明显线程数量一大资源成本会上得很快。2.4. Java 21 虚拟线程为什么必须单独说到了Java 21, 这个图景, 已经没办法仅仅用“Java线程重”去进行概括了。虚拟线程是这样的, 它不像传统平台线程那般, 从创建起便始终绑定某一个OS线程等情况了, 它是由Java调度的, 运行的时候会挂载到哪里哪里之上, 阻塞之际还能够卸下来的, 这就是虚拟线程的情况。这意味着一件很重要的事在“线程数量受OS线程直接限制”此问题之上, Java因虚拟线程, 已被往回拉了一大截。所以, 现在, 再来回答, “Go为什么比Java多线程快”, 这时候, 必须, 先补上, 一句版本前提。2.5. 三者先用一张表对齐维度Go 平台线程Java 虚拟线程大量创建的并发单位是否通常 1:1 占 OS 线程初始成本更小更大明显低于平台线程阻塞 I/O 时是否继续长期占着 OS 线程通常不需要通常会通常不会最适合的优势场景高并发、阻塞多通用但规模上来后成本高高吞吐阻塞任务结论关键词更容易把并发做便宜线程模型直观但更重更强调 scale不是单线程更快看到这里后面的问题就顺了。真正致使 Go 给人感觉更为轻量的缘由, 并非将其称作美妙之称谓这方面所为, 而是自起始阶段, 便根本未曾把单个并发任务径直弄成单个操作系统线程这般情况。3. 为什么 Go 更容易把并发做便宜这一节不再泛泛说“协程轻”。直接拆成本。3.1. 创建一万个任务谁先变贵传统Java平台那里线程的创建, 从本质上来说是在朝着OS去申请并且建立起一个真实存在的线程。线程一旦数量变多起来, 栈空间、调度元数据以及内核资源都会随之往上提升起来。Go 不是这样。从很小的起点起始的用户栈, g结构自身也会进行复用, 进而同样是“我要再挂1万个等待下游结果的任务”这种情况, Go更像是去多摆放1万个轻量任务对象, 而非多开启1万个完整的OS线程。这一步所存在的差距, 于请求量尚未提升之际不见得会显得突出, 然而一旦并发度有所提高极容易直接演变成关乎系统是否能够持续接纳任务的问题。3.2. 任务切换为什么不必每次都惊动内核Go的调度器, 会将可运行的, 进行分发处理, 使其分布到不同的P之上, 每个P, 都会对自身的本地队列予以维护, 在处于空闲状态的时候, 还能够前往别的地方, 去偷取任务。这意味着两件事这地方最为值钱的并非是“永远无需内核”这种情况, 而是存在着这么一种状况: 存在规模数量众多的排队, 后续还有唤醒以及迁移等情况, 并且在不少时候, 这些情况在内部就已经被消化处理掉了。要是每增添一个并发任务, 皆等同于多了一个内核线程, 那么内核调度器所目睹的压力将会极为直观。有鉴于此, Go将这部分压力向用户态进行了一定程度的分流。3.3. 一旦开始等 I/O差距就被放大真实将距离显著拉开变大的, 常常并非是“构建一项任务”, 而是“这一任务后续得等待漫长的时长”。高并发后端服务里最常见的等待是什么这时候谁能把“等待”做便宜谁就更容易扛住并发。Go 在这里为什么更占便宜Go当中存在着这样一种特别的运行机制, 当处于等待网络I/O这种状态的时候, 那些相关的进程能够选择先暂先暂缓运行, 而不用持续着在某个特定的执行位置上占据着资源。并且, 哪怕陷入阻塞, Go同样会尽力将P从当前M之上拆解开来, 以使另外的M接过来继续运行其余的。由于处于高并发服务当中, 实际上数量更多的是‘同时处于等待状态’的任务, 而非‘同时处于计算状态’的任务。只要在等待的这段时间之内不需要持续占据一个完整的操作系统线程, 那么并发规模就比较容易提升上去。传统 Java 平台线程为什么更容易先撞墙传统平台线程碰到阻塞I/O之际, 往往便是此线程跟底层OS线程一块儿去等。线程池为什么会那么重要原因就在这里。大量的人认为, Java服务一旦数量增多, 首先是在“计算方面应付不过来”, 实际上常常并非如此。它更仿若: 还没到计算应付不过来的时候, 就先出现等待方面应付不过来了。Java 虚拟线程为什么会改写结论虚拟线程有着这样的设计目标, 那便是要让“阻塞等待之际还始终占据着一个平台线程”这种情况变得成本更低。官方文档表述得相当直白: 虚拟线程适用于具备高吞吐特点、阻塞类任务, 它们并非那种速度更快的线程, 而是属于更易于扩展规模的线程。Go在阻塞场景里所展现给人的那种优势, 实际上已经开始在同一类问题上渐渐落下了。这就是这和它的形势走向啊。因此, 于今日而言, 要是有人依旧将“Java 线程天生重”视作绝对的结论, 那么这已然过时了。更为确切的表述是:3.4. 并发一高线程数量就先变成瓶颈在做服务之际, 存在着这样一个极为平常却易懂的情况, 即要是平均延迟保持不变, 而吞吐想要提升上去, 那么与此同时, 在系统当中挂着未处理的请求数量也必然得随之一起提升上去。这就是为什么高并发服务里问题很容易先暴露在线程模型。举个最小直觉例子。假设存在一个请求, 其平均所需时间为100毫秒, 目标吞吐为每秒10,000个请求那么系统里同时挂着的请求便会显得非常多。此间大部分请求并非都在疯狂使用CPU, 它们有可能只是处于等待网络状态, 或者等待数据库, 亦或是等待下游服务。在这个时段, 要是出现 “一个请求差不多要长期占住一个平台线程” 这种状况, 那么线程数量会很快变成瓶颈。而要是 “一个请求仅仅对应一个更轻的用户态任务, 并且在这类任务处于等待状态之时还能够挂起让步”, 如此一来整个系统可以挂住的并发量自然就会更高咯。Go, 在线上的时候, 常常会显得更具备能够扛住的特质, 从本质上来说, 就是它更加容易, 把这一批处于“正在等”这种状态的请求, 以较为便宜的方式挂起来。4. 为什么传统 Java 线程版经常显得更慢这里所讲的“慢”, 在许多情形下, 并非意味着业务代码运行迟缓, 而是表明系统整体的从首起到终了的过程, 开始呈现出更多的、异于常规的层级结构特点。4.1. 线程池为什么会先变成主战场通常走这套组合的为传统Java服务, 目的是不让线程无限膨胀。这套东西当然并非缺点, 它属于在更为侧重线程模型情形下的必要工程化举措, 是这样无疑的。然而, 它存在着一个副作用, 那就是, 请求常常尚未真的进入到业务计算环节, 就已然先在“等待被执行”这一步骤的进程中消耗掉时间了。这意味着, 在不少情形下, 你所体会到的“Go 更快”, 并非只因 Go 当中的某一段业务逻辑仅仅耗费了 5 毫秒, 而 Java 却耗费了 20 毫秒。而是于是最终表现出来的是吞吐和尾延迟的差异。4.2. 为什么等待会扩散成整体变慢阻塞最怕什么最怕等待时间本身不干活但资源还得一直占着。传统平台线程的问题正是这样线程于是就跟着持续保持挂着的状态。等到处于挂着状态的线程数量变得越发多时 , 线程池进行扩容这样的情况 , 以及上下文切换的状况 , 还有栈空间被占用的情形 , 甚至于队列等待所产生的这些成本 , 就会一同接连冒出来。前面讲的是直觉这里把创建、切换、等待三笔账并排摆开。它当然不是精确 但足够把三笔账摆在同一张桌子上4.3. 别把它说成 Java 语言慢许多人将“传统Java线程版更易于出现变慢的情况”, 替换成“Java自身就是运行速度迟缓的语言”, 这二者是完全不同的两码事。Java 的热点代码, 不是这篇文章要反驳的对象、JIT 优化, 不是这篇文章要反驳的对象、成熟的 GC, 不是这篇文章要反驳的对象、工具链, 不是这篇文章要反驳的对象。这里要说的只有一句处于高并发阻塞场景之中时, 传统Java平台线程, 用来承载并发的成本, 越发容易率先转变成为瓶颈。主语是传统线程模型不是整个 Java 生态。5. 为什么这不是绝对结论提到这儿, 要是径直作出结论说“所以 Go 就整体比 Java 快”, 那么之前铺陈的边界就都化为泡影了。 标点符号为句号。5.1. 纯 CPU 密集场景Java 完全可能更强倘若任务大体上不存在阻塞情况, 核心矛盾在于热点代码要怎样运行得更为迅速, 那么Java的JIT极有可能展示出很强的表现。这时候决定结果的不再是“能挂多少等待中的任务”而是所以, 针对于CPU密集型任务, 不能直接原封不动地搬用“Go更快”这句话。5.2. Java 21 虚拟线程已经把结论改了一半该官方文档着重去专门表示强调说明过, 虚拟线程并非是那种速度更快的线程, 它们存在的意义是针对scale。它的意思是这恰好也是 Go 过去最常被拿来称赞的地方。放到今天的工程语境里可以把结论收成三条5.3. Go 也不是没有代价Go 便宜不等于 Go 没成本。下面这些情况Go 一样会掉坑所以, Go 的优势并不在于“不会慢”, 反而是在那些比如说高并发阻塞任务这样代表性极为典型突出的服务场景当中, 它能够相对更容易地能够去把成本给压低到一个让人感觉更加舒坦适宜毫无压力的位置之上。6. 面试里怎么把这题答得既短又不浅倘若面试官询问的是, “为何Go的多线程相比Java要快”, 一种稳妥的回答方式并非直接背诵, “协程轻”。6.1. 面试里的短答版可以这么答这道题多数情形下比的并非单线程执行速率, 而乃高并发阻塞情境下的并发承载代价。Go 里众多并发单元是 , 并不径直等同于 OS 线程, 栈起始更小, 调度在 里开展, 阻塞 I/O 尚能借由 把等待代价摊薄传统 Java 平台线程通常 1:1 对应 OS 线程, 故而线程增多之后, 栈、调度以及阻塞等待代价更易于率先显现出来。6.2. 再将版本边界补齐。再补一句边界但这并不意味着, 在所有的场景当中, Go都会比Java快。若是CPU密集型的热点代码, Java或许会更强。另外, Java 21推出的虚拟线程, 已经显著地缩小了传统线程模型, 在高并发阻塞场景下的短板。所以, 在今天回答这道问题的时候, 最好将平台线程与虚拟线程分开来进行阐述。这样收口答案既有主线也有版本前提。7. 最后把开头那个现象收回来就是说, 究竟是出于何种缘由, 好多人竟然觉着 Go 的那个所谓“多线程”, 相较于 Java 的“多线程”而言, 速度上要更快哩, 这是为啥?更准确的说法其实是很多后端的场景里面, Go 以更低成本挂住大量并发的任务是更加容易做到的状态, 特别是那些大部分时间都处于等待 I/O 的这样一些任务。它快的不是一句空泛的“语言更先进”而是三件很具体的事如果比较对象是传统 Java 平台线程这个结论通常成立。倘若说比较的对象此刻已然切换成为 Java 21 虚拟线程的话, 那么主线所涉及的内容便不再是“到底谁从一开始就具有更重的特性”, 相反是双方都在全力以赴地将高并发阻塞任务的承载所需成本给想方设法地降低。把这层讲清这道题才算真的答到点上。WWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/69883.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/91815.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/49233.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63946.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/81159.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/68625.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/47594.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75609.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/58865.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17853.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/18614.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50977.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/81035.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/43728.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/05031.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/31761.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/86354.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/66768.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/00774.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/76484.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/45341.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/97385.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63708.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/66855.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/57552.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/24699.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/05318.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75399.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/98675.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/62876.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/67101.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/23927.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/51603.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/22822.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/67610.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/27596.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94307.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/30608.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/80337.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/76405.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/44205.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/16491.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/42016.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75567.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/71394.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/35573.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/20374.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/80361.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/80210.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17697.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/15424.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/46635.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/88813.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54624.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/10965.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/56828.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/41512.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/71511.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/73328.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/07001.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14193.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/73386.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/40959.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17175.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54003.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/68696.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17535.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/03284.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/13496.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/83468.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/08256.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/76840.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/24461.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/76255.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/73408.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/53531.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/37721.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/88289.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/20848.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/35001.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/65936.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/26141.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/12075.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/37069.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/59753.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/57991.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/57236.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/09096.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/00596.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/43946.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/59326.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/34379.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/91786.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/21231.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/65097.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/43897.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/96400.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/37620.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/37504.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/95213.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/89060.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75299.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/52740.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/98475.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/36940.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/24381.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/08229.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/34530.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/71018.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17760.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/42212.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/60405.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/09681.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/53939.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/68838.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/89666.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/96800.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/99765.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/46601.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/58580.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/74324.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/26114.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/62241.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50765.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/20426.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/84871.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14600.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/21198.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/52026.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/23097.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/29900.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/06692.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54734.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/66986.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94003.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/20173.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/95570.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/80452.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/81681.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54631.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/22913.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/49959.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/29303.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/85945.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/03344.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/39258.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/02217.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14501.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/03863.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/10546.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/19646.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/95714.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/34585.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/71299.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14768.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/17968.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/22591.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/23830.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14235.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/99436.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/53451.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/28063.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/47039.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/78849.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/60446.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/00515.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50157.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/48178.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/46005.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/04246.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/45243.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/59618.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/40481.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54257.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/55991.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/25033.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/47698.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/04872.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/03889.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/04934.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/80555.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/26972.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/21048.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/42310.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/37243.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/82579.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/06194.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/07706.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/74684.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/14381.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94069.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94586.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/46502.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/89237.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/91375.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75778.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/67365.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/91458.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/18712.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/65113.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/64447.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/42833.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/08840.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/40269.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/44864.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94623.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/36361.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/51273.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/11899.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/43336.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/93747.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/51998.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/51541.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/55562.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/62762.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/74572.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/41350.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/61556.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/15480.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63497.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/90319.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/21428.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/40289.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/25790.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/98597.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/36526.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/31803.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63453.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/69405.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/20445.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/16721.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/38943.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/69301.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/57958.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/49203.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/67094.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/84939.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/07093.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/90262.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/31335.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63501.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/00955.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/45711.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/26883.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/66568.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/96154.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/21495.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50397.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/19499.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/76621.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/98174.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/70495.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/72692.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50904.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/38961.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/36419.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/97934.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/97978.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54937.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/46528.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/87661.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/23833.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/87244.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/68288.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/35299.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63589.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/72216.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/78714.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/65238.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/10783.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75759.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/52424.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/75162.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/18681.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/28210.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/53516.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/47834.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/18310.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/86641.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/12691.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/59776.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/67370.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/30926.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/33855.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/48267.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/94242.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/82517.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/31274.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/86958.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/63779.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/50181.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/89313.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/42888.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/54664.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/27672.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/11210.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/81693.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/61835.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/36459.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/59565.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/35769.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/48931.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/24835.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/70506.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/28298.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/41741.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/27923.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/83147.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/79973.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/16532.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/79933.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/07429.sHtMLWWw.Shaer.Shricgs.cN/Article/details/73887.sHtML